The latest preliminary figures from data provider Cotality show that the national auction clearance rate has dropped to 44%, marking the weakest result since April 2020. This level of clearance, defined as the percentage of home auctions that result in a recorded sale, coincides with the early weeks of the pandemic when lockdowns upended the housing sector. While the reasons for the slump are vastly different from 2020, the outcome for sellers is similar: fewer than half of the homes hitting the block are finding buyers. This represents a significant cooling in an economy where the housing market has traditionally been a primary driver of household wealth and consumption.
The decline in clearance rates is occurring against a backdrop of sharply reduced auction volumes. Across the capital cities, Cotality logged 1,888 auctions in the most recent week. While this figure is 11.4% higher than the previous week, it remains 41.1% below the number recorded in the same week a year ago. Tom Hawley, director of Azura Financial, noted that the contraction is stark. “There was about 1,800 auctions over the weekend,” Hawley told Today. “You know, 12 months ago it was well over 3,000 auctions. So there’s a lot less properties actually going to auction at the moment.” This drop in supply suggests that many vendors are choosing to withdraw their listings, likely hoping to ride out the downturn rather than sell at depressed prices.

The primary driver of this market correction is the cost of borrowing. The Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has raised the cash rate to 4.85%, the highest level in 18 years, in a bid to curb inflation. This monetary tightening is directly impacting household budgets and financing capacity. The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) reported that the value of newly originated home loans fell 15.5% in the September quarter, a decline nearly twice the size of economists’ expectations. Investor lending was hit even harder, dropping 32.3% by value in the same period. For buyers, this means that the monthly repayment burden has increased substantially, pushing many potential purchasers out of the market or causing them to delay major financial decisions until there is greater certainty regarding interest rates and price stability.
Policy changes have compounded the pressure on the market. The May budget included measures that trimmed tax perks for property investors, further discouraging speculative activity. As a result, the market is no longer driven solely by investor demand but is increasingly reliant on owner-occupiers who are cautious about entering a falling price environment. Ray White Victoria Chief Auctioneer Luke Banitsiotis explained that while there is still time for vendors to achieve results before Christmas, the dynamic has shifted. “However, the momentum currently comes with a caveat,” Banitsiotis said. “Auctions are driving action, but only when the price sits at a level the market actually wants to engage with. If the pricing makes sense, the buyers will show up and compete.”
This sentiment is reflected in the data for individual capital cities, where performance varies but the downward trend is consistent. Sydney hosted 716 auctions, a 3.5% increase week-on-week but 42% below the previous year. Its preliminary clearance rate was 48.1%, the first time it had dipped below 50% since spring began. Melbourne saw 692 auctions, up 16.5% from the prior week but down 52.3% year-over-year. The Victorian capital’s clearance rate eased to 47.8%, its lowest level since September 2021. Brisbane presented a different picture in terms of volume, hosting 235 auctions, which was a 9.8% increase from a year ago, placing it as one of the few capitals with higher activity than last year. However, its clearance rate was only 25.3%, a figure that has stayed under 30% in five of the past seven weeks, indicating that even in markets with growing auction volumes, the conversion rate remains weak.

Despite the low clearance rates, indicators of buyer interest have not vanished entirely. Record open-home attendance suggests that potential buyers are still active in the market, touring properties and assessing their options. The challenge for agents is converting this interest into sales. The disconnect between attendance and clearance rates implies that while buyers are present, they are choosier and more sensitive to price. As Hawley noted, “If the market’s going to continue falling, it’s hard to have that confidence and certainty to be able to make a major financial decision and buy a property.” This hesitation is creating a standoff where sellers must adjust their pricing expectations to align with the reduced purchasing power of buyers.
The broader economic implications of this housing slump are significant. A cooler housing market tends to weigh on volumes for brokers, developers, and building suppliers. It may also ease some pressure on prices and inflation, a factor the RBA will monitor closely. With inflation continuing to fall outside the RBA’s target, the central bank is unlikely to cut rates in the immediate future, maintaining the high-cost-of-capital environment. For the seller at 30 McCarthy Grove, the premium achieved over the reserve price was a victory, but it relied on a specific alignment of pricing and demand that is not universal. As the market moves toward the end of the year, the key question for households and investors alike is whether the current price corrections will stabilize demand or if the high interest rates will continue to suppress transaction volumes, keeping the market in a state of prolonged uncertainty.



