The incident occurred on Wednesday morning when Mr. Rogoff, a former judge and veteran state and federal prosecutor, was sworn in as U.S. Attorney before 8 a.m. at the U.S. courthouse in downtown Seattle. According to Mr. Rogoff, he subsequently went to the U.S. Attorney’s Office to meet with Charles Neil Floyd, whose 120-day interim term in the position had expired in February. While waiting in the lobby, Mr. Rogoff received an email from the Trump administration informing him of his removal. He has stated that he is consulting with other lawyers regarding the possibility of filing a lawsuit over the firing.
The core of the legal controversy centers on the mechanism for filling vacancies in U.S. Attorney positions. Under standard practice, the President appoints U.S. Attorneys, who must then be confirmed by the Senate. However, temporary appointments are permitted when a confirmed nominee is not immediately available. When the term of a temporary appointee expires before a nominee is confirmed, federal judges within the district have the authority to name a U.S. Attorney. In this instance, the Justice Department had appointed Mr. Floyd, a former immigration judge, as interim U.S. Attorney in October but did not forward his nomination to the Senate. Upon the expiration of his interim term, the administration shifted Mr. Floyd’s title to “first assistant U.S. attorney,” leaving the top post vacant.
Acting U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche defended the removal in a social media post, stating, “District court judges can appoint a temporary U.S. Attorney, and [the president] can fire them.” Blanche further criticized the judges who appointed Mr. Rogoff, alleging they “abandoned the time-honored process of consultation with the administration so that the selected U.S. Attorney is qualified to serve in the administration.” The administration’s strategy appears to rely on the ability to terminate judicially appointed interim officials, a stance that contrasts with the traditional understanding of judicial independence in staffing vacancies.
The judicial process leading to Mr. Rogoff’s appointment was deliberate. After the interim term ended, the federal judges in the district opened the position to applications and appointed a bipartisan panel to review candidates. On Wednesday, the court, comprising 17 active and senior judges appointed by five different presidents, issued a unanimous order naming Mr. Rogoff the U.S. Attorney for western Washington. Senator Patty Murray, a Democrat from Washington who had previously opposed Mr. Floyd’s candidacy, condemned the quick firing, noting that Mr. Rogoff had demonstrated a commitment to public service and was “appointed legally by the federal judges.”
This dispute in Seattle is part of a broader pattern of legal challenges regarding the status of unconfirmed federal prosecutors. In a parallel development in the Western District of Virginia, defense attorney Paul Beers is seeking the dismissal of a charge against his client that was authorized by Robert Tracci. Mr. Tracci leads the U.S. Attorney’s Office but has not been nominated by the President or confirmed by the Senate. Beers argues that Mr. Tracci’s appointment violated the presidential appointment and Senate confirmation process, often referred to as the PAS process. U.S. District Judge Robert Ballou is scheduled to hear oral arguments on this claim on December 22.
In his court filing, Beers cited similar cases in New Jersey, New York, and Nevada, where courts found that the appointments of first assistant U.S. Attorneys were invalid. “The executive branch machinations outlined above with respect to Mr. Tracci are consistent with the Office of Attorney General’s recent prosecutor shufflings and reshufflings elsewhere,” Beers wrote. “No bureaucratic titles or sleights of hand can overcome Mr. Tracci’s failure to undergo the PAS process.” The Department of Justice has not yet responded to questions regarding these legal challenges.
The legal landscape is further complicated by prior judicial skepticism regarding the administration’s personnel maneuvers. In May, a U.S. appeals court panel expressed doubts about the legality of shifting an interim prosecutor’s title to “first assistant” while leaving the U.S. Attorney position vacant. This tactic, which the administration has reportedly tried in other federal judicial districts, aims to maintain unconfirmed prosecutors in their roles indefinitely. The immediate removal of Mr. Rogoff highlights the fragility of judicially appointed interim positions and raises unresolved questions about the separation of powers in federal prosecutorial appointments. Mr. Rogoff is currently considering legal action, which could provide a definitive judicial interpretation of whether the President may unilaterally remove a U.S. Attorney appointed by a district court panel.



