Politics

Constitutional Crisis Looms as Legal Theories for a Third Trump Term Surface Amidst Institutional Pushback

The hearing began with Coons linking the role of federal judges to the obligation of defending the Constitution. “Since we’re just talking about the importance of taking the oath to uphold and defend the Constitution, Mr. Sullivan, can you just tell me what the 22nd Amendment provides?” Coons asked. Sullivan hesitated, acknowledging difficulty in recalling the specific text. “Senator, if I’m remembering correctly—and I carry it over my heart because sometimes it isn’t in my brain—but if I, if I’m remembering it correctly, it is…” Sullivan said, pausing to express further uncertainty. When Coons offered the opening words, “No person shall be elected…,” Sullivan recognized the language, responding, “Ah yes!” He subsequently identified the restriction as a two-election limit for the presidency. However, when Coons shifted the discussion to the practical application of this limit, asking if President Trump had been elected and served twice, Sullivan diverted to a discussion on the certification of Trump’s election victories in 2016 and 2024, without directly affirming the constitutional constraint on a third candidacy.

This judicial ambiguity arrives at a critical juncture in U.S. politics. President Trump, who began his second term in 2025, has been “toying with the idea” of running for a third term since before his inauguration. According to Common Cause for Reform (CREW), a nonpartisan government integrity organization, Trump and his political allies have floated this prospect on numerous occasions, despite the explicit prohibition in the 22nd Amendment. The amendment, ratified on February 27, 1951, states: “No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice.” It further clarifies eligibility for those who succeed to the presidency, ensuring that serving in an unfinished term does not count as a full election term. The ratification process in 1951 was swift and broad, with 41 state legislatures approving the measure between 1947 and 1951, often with bipartisan support, representing every region of the country.

Photo by Tara Winstead on Pexels

Despite the clear textual language, a new legal theory has emerged to challenge the amendment’s finality. In December 2025, *The Wall Street Journal* reported that renowned lawyer Alan Dershowitz, who assisted Trump during the impeachment proceedings of his first term, provided the President with a draft of his upcoming book, tentatively titled “Could President Trump Constitutionally Serve a Third Term?” Dershowitz argues that the Constitution is “ambiguous” on the question of a third term. His proposed workaround involves a scenario where, if Trump were declared the winner of another election, members of the Electoral College would abstain from voting. Dershowitz contends that in such a vacuum, the election would be decided by Congress, which would “select, and not elect, the president.” This distinction, he argues, circumvents the 22nd Amendment’s restriction on being “elected” more than twice. Another avenue suggested is for Trump to run for Speaker of the House, a role that does not require membership in Congress, potentially leveraging that position to influence his return to the White House.

Critics and legal scholars, however, view these maneuvers as an attempt to delegitimize the rule of law. CREW Executive Director Donald K. Sherman and colleagues have published analyses, including a forthcoming piece in the *Kentucky Law Journal* titled “The Ironclad Twenty-Second Amendment,” arguing that such interpretations are legally unsound. Sherman notes that while President Trump recently commented in a *Vanity Fair* interview that it is “pretty clear” he is not allowed to run again, his repeated threats to seek a third term overshadow this concession. “We’ve tracked hundreds of conflicts of interest and filed 160+ legal actions over the last two years,” CREW stated, emphasizing its commitment to holding the administration accountable. The organization has filed Freedom of Information Act requests and researched the historical ratification of the amendment to counter these novel legal arguments.

Photo by Harun Tan on Pexels

The political reaction to these developments has been sharply divided along partisan lines. In Michigan, State Representative Noah Arbit (D-West Bloomfield) introduced House Resolution 153 on August 19, reaffirming support for the 22nd Amendment and rejecting any claims that would weaken it. “Nothing could be more vital than abiding by the Constitution and upholding the rule of law, especially if you are the President of the United States,” Arbit stated. However, the resolution was not heard on the floor of the State House, as the Republican Majority refused to consider it. This legislative stalling tactic mirrors the broader national debate, where institutional mechanisms are being tested by executive actions that push the boundaries of constitutional precedent.

The historical context of the 22nd Amendment underscores the significance of the current controversy. Debates over term limits began with the ratification of the Constitution itself, where figures like Alexander Hamilton and James Madison had envisioned a president serving for life, a concept that raised concerns about the potential for a monarchy. The modern amendment was a direct response to the precedent set by Franklin D. Roosevelt, who was elected to four terms. The ratification of the 22nd Amendment was a bipartisan consensus that sought to prevent the accumulation of excessive executive power. Today, that consensus is being strained. While Republican leaders in some jurisdictions, like the Michigan State House, have blocked formal affirmations of the amendment, legal scholars like Dershowitz are providing intellectual cover for a third-term bid. The uncertainty remains whether the executive branch will move beyond rhetorical threats to actual legal challenges, or if the judiciary, guided by the text of the Constitution, will firmly close the door on a third term. The next critical development will likely hinge on whether any formal legal or legislative action is taken to test Dershowitz’s theories, or if the President’s recent concessions in media interviews will serve as a final retreat from the idea.

Laura Bennett

Laura Bennett covers political developments, elections, government policy, and major changes within political parties. Her work focuses on explaining the substance behind headlines, including how new proposals, legislation, and political decisions may affect the public. Laura brings a measured approach to fast-moving stories and relies on official information and credible reporting.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button