The Case for Stability at No. 5
In the Wellington match, India chased a target of 135 after restricting New Zealand to 134. The chase was fraught with difficulty, with India reduced to 113 for 7 before rain ended play. Axar Patel, sent in at No. 5, was dismissed for seven runs off 17 balls, caught by Jacob Duffy off Matt Fisher. His departure left India 47 for 4 in the 13th over. KL Rahul, batting at No. 6, subsequently partnered with Shreyas Iyer to stabilize the innings. Iyer scored 30, while Rahul finished unbeaten on 26, the two highest scores in India’s chase.
This performance, alongside Rahul’s broader record, has prompted former players and analysts to argue that Patel is not the right long-term solution for the No. 5 slot in conditions that favor pace and bounce. Former India pacer Dodda Ganesh was particularly vocal, stating: “I say it again: Axar Patel can’t be your no 5 in SENA countries. He could play a cameo here and there but he’s definitely not a long term solution. You are denying KL Rahul the game time #NZvIND.”
Cricbuzz’s Deepu Narayan offered a nuanced view, acknowledging Patel’s specific utility in Asia. “Axar at #5 had a well defined role in Asia: left-handed spin hitter breaking the run of right handers in top 4 and did a commendable job,” Narayan wrote. However, he argued that this role “does not carry over to pace-friendly conditions in SENA. Especially with KL Rahul in the lineup.”
Statistical Divergence
The statistical argument for Rahul’s precedence is compelling. In 36 innings at No. 5 in ODIs, Rahul has scored 1,646 runs at an average of 68.58 and a strike rate of 103.19. His consistency is underscored by four centuries, 10 fifties, and 12 not-outs, with no dismissal for a duck in the position. In contrast, Axar Patel has scored 365 runs in 13 innings at No. 5, averaging 30.41 at a strike rate of 87.11, with no centuries to his name.
| Player | Innings at No. 5 | Runs | Average | Strike Rate | 100s |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KL Rahul | 36 | 1,646 | 68.58 | 103.19 | 4 |
| Axar Patel | 13 | 365 | 30.41 | 87.11 | 0 |
Rahul averages more than twice as much as Patel and scores approximately 16 runs more per 100 balls. Given that the 2027 ODI World Cup is set to be held in SENA conditions, these figures suggest that the stability Rahul provides at No. 5 is a critical asset for a team aiming for title contention.
Defending the Batsman
Rahul has faced significant online criticism, particularly following India’s narrow defeat to England in the series-deciding ODI at Lord’s. In that match, Rahul was dismissed for 12 after Rohit Sharma’s magnificent 137, as India fell short of chasing 387. Following that loss, former player Dodda Ganesh defended Rahul from what he described as “toxic online hate and cyberbullying.”
“The reason KL Rahul faces so much hate and bullying online despite his unreal numbers and versatility in ODIs, is accounts like these,” Ganesh wrote, referencing sarcastic posts questioning if Rahul was being thanked for his efforts. “The game was practically over by the time KL came to bat at no 6, but who gets the blame? It’s KL again.”
Despite the scrutiny, Rahul’s form over his last ten ODI innings shows a pattern of run-scoring, with three significant contributions noted in recent analysis. His ability to anchor the innings, as seen in Wellington where he batted alongside Iyer to rebuild the chase, highlights his value in high-pressure situations.
Recent Form and Selection Implications
While the ODI debate centers on Rahul’s role, his recent Test form has been inconsistent. In the unofficial Test between New Zealand A and India A in Lincoln, Rahul struggled, scoring 0 and 4. He was dismissed hit-wicket in the fifth over of the second innings, contributing to India A’s collapse to 113. However, this unofficial match, designed to assess players for the upcoming Test series, is distinct from the ODI format where his record dictates the selection logic.
As India prepares for future challenges, the selectors face a clear tactical choice. Axar Patel offers a unique left-handed spin-hitting option that disrupts the rhythm of right-handed batters, a tactic that has proven effective in Asian conditions. However, in the pace-friendly environments of New Zealand, Australia, and the SENA region, the statistical evidence strongly favors KL Rahul at No. 5. With the 2027 ODI World Cup approaching, the preference for Rahul’s consistency and high strike rate in these conditions appears to be the more prudent strategic decision.
The next major test for India’s middle order will come as they continue their tour and prepare for the upcoming Test series, where different dynamics will apply. However, for the 50-over format, the data points to a clear hierarchy: in SENA conditions, KL Rahul is the calm and the calculated choice at No. 5.



