Law & Justice

Italian Voters Reject Meloni’s Judicial Overhaul in Landmark Referendum

The referendum centered on Constitutional Amendment n. 1353-B, a package of changes designed to fundamentally alter the composition and governance of Italy’s judiciary. The core legal question was whether to separate the career paths of judges and prosecutors, which had previously been grouped collectively under the umbrella of “magistrates.” Under the existing constitutional framework, Article 104 of the Italian Constitution governed the National Council of the Judiciary (CSM), the self-governing body responsible for appointments, promotions, and disciplinary actions. The proposed reform sought to split this unified body into two distinct councils and replace the peer-election system for judicial members with one based on sortition, or random selection by lot.

Meloni’s government argued that the reform was essential to guarantee impartiality and modernize a judicial system widely criticized for being slow and bureaucratic. The administration maintained that allowing prosecutors to become judges later in their careers undermined public trust and created a “para-mafia mechanism” within the judiciary, a phrase used by Justice Minister Carlo Nordio in public disputes with legal professionals. The government posited that separating the roles and stripping the CSM of disciplinary powers in favor of a new High Disciplinary Court would streamline operations and reduce political influence within the courts.

Photo by SAIF SIDDIQUE on Pexels

Conversely, the opposition, led by the center-left Democratic Party, framed the measure as a political power grab that would concentrate authority in the executive branch and erode institutional checks and balances. Elly Schlein, leader of the Democratic Party, argued that the proposal was poorly drafted and would weaken the independence of the judiciary. Legal scholars and civil society groups echoed these concerns; Benedetta Lobina, a legal fellow at the University College Dublin, noted that the reform failed to address pressing issues such as prison overcrowding or lengthy trials, instead deflecting attention with structural changes that raised questions about the government’s true intentions. The opposition argued that replacing elected peers with randomly selected members would dilute the professional expertise required for judicial oversight.

The campaign was marked by intense polarization and documented friction between the executive and the judiciary. More than 80% of members of the National Magistrates Association had staged a one-day strike in the preceding year in protest against the proposed changes. Tensions escalated in the final weeks before the vote, with high-ranking government officials making inflammatory statements. Giusi Bartolozzi, the chief of staff to Justice Minister Nordio, drew widespread criticism after stating on a talk show that the reform would “get rid of” magistrates who operated like “execution squads.” Such rhetoric, combined with Nordio’s dismissal of judicial criticism as “petulant litanies,” fueled the “No” campaign’s narrative that the government was hostile to judicial autonomy.

The legal implications of the rejection are immediate and significant. Because the constitutional amendment failed to secure the necessary majority in the referendum, Articles 87, 102, 104, 105, 106, 107, and 110 of the Italian Constitution remain unchanged. The National Council of the Judiciary continues to operate as a single body, retaining its current powers over the career paths of magistrates and disciplinary procedures. The proposed High Disciplinary Court will not be established, and the career paths for judges and prosecutors remain unified. This outcome preserves the existing system of judicial self-governance, where magistrates elect their peers to the CSM, a structure that critics of the current system have long argued lacks transparency but which the voting public has now reaffirmed by rejecting its dismantling.

Photo by Tara Winstead on Pexels

Politically, the result has exposed fractures within Meloni’s ruling coalition. The referendum had become a de facto confidence test for the Prime Minister’s leadership, particularly as she had staked her reputation on the promise of judicial modernization. Despite the defeat, Meloni pledged to complete her mandate, which runs into 2027. In a video statement posted on Instagram, she acknowledged the result, stating, “Italian citizens have decided and we respect their decision as always.” She characterized the loss as “a missed opportunity to modernize Italy” but vowed to continue governing with “responsibility, determination, and above all, with respect for Italy and its people.”

The defeat leaves the structural challenges of the Italian justice system unresolved. The issues of procedural delays, bureaucratic inefficiency, and prison overcrowding that prompted the reform attempt remain unaddressed by legislative action. The next confirmed legal step for the government will be to return to ordinary legislative processes to address any remaining administrative inefficiencies, though the constitutional framework governing judicial independence remains intact as it was before the amendment was proposed. The referendum result stands as a documented rejection of the executive’s attempt to restructure the judiciary’s internal governance, reinforcing the status quo of the constitutional separation of powers.

Jessica Brown

Jessica Brown reports on legal and justice matters, including court rulings, government regulation, legislation, constitutional questions, and major cases. She works to make complicated legal developments accessible without stripping away important context. Jessica's reporting is grounded in official documents and verified information, with particular care given to distinguishing claims made in court from established findings.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button