In a recent statement, Letby’s barrister indicated that the defence has “no doubt” the case will be revisited by the Court of Appeal. This assertion comes despite the fact that the Court of Appeal has already refused permission for an appeal in this matter. The decision to pursue further legal avenues highlights the ongoing tension between the judicial findings of the original trial and the broader systemic critiques emerging from the post-conviction inquiries.
The central legal development here is the persistence of the appeal process against the backdrop of a comprehensive institutional review. The principal legal question remains whether the original conviction withstands scrutiny on the merits of the evidence, a matter the Court of Appeal has previously adjudicated by refusing permission to proceed. While the inquiry did not find evidence of wrongful conviction, it did produce a damning assessment of the environment in which the crimes allegedly occurred.
Lady Justice Thirlwall, who led the independent inquiry, found a “complete failure” of safeguarding, management, and governance at the Countess of Chester Hospital. The report detailed how some of the deaths could have been prevented, citing “almost every page” as containing opportunities where action could have been taken, according to Tamlin Bolton, the solicitor for seven of the affected families. The inquiry identified specific failures, including the hospital’s decision to shed highly qualified Advanced Neonatal Nurse Practitioners to save approximately £300,000, a move that critics argue sacrificed expertise for financial expediency.
Thirlwall’s judgment was also personally critical of Letby, noting she was “repeatedly untruthful in her dealings with friends and colleagues.” One notable example cited in the report involved a message Letby sent to a colleague regarding the death of Baby A, in which she claimed the father was “on the floor crying.” The baby’s mother told the inquiry this simply never happened, and Thirlwall agreed that Letby’s behavior should have been a red flag. These findings reinforce the narrative that the individual’s conduct was a significant factor in the events, supporting the prosecution’s case rather than undermining it.
Despite this, the defence’s intent to appeal suggests they believe there are procedural or evidentiary grounds yet to be fully exhausted. The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which handles applications for potential miscarriages of justice, confirmed in February 2025 that it had received a preliminary application on Letby’s behalf. The CCRC stated that work had begun to assess the application and that further submissions were anticipated. They emphasized that it is not their role to determine innocence or guilt, but rather to investigate whether there is a realistic prospect of success on appeal.
The legal landscape surrounding this case is complex, with arguments often extending beyond the immediate facts of the trial to broader institutional critiques. Some commentators have drawn historical parallels, such as the “appalling vista” described by Lord Denning in the context of the Birmingham Six, suggesting that if a conviction were overturned, it would expose failures across multiple arms of the state, including policing and NHS management. However, these arguments remain speculative until a court formally reviews the case. The current status is one of procedural uncertainty: the conviction stands, the inquiry has validated the seriousness of the hospital’s failings, but the legal door to the Court of Appeal remains technically open for the defence to push through.
The public consequences of these legal maneuvers are significant. The release of a Netflix documentary featuring detectives, families, and medical experts has kept the case in the global spotlight, complicating the narrative with mixed perspectives. For the families involved, the focus remains on the lessons learned from the inquiry, such as the recommendation to install cameras monitoring every neonatal cot with livestream access for parents, and to restrict access to insulin, which was allegedly used in the poisonings. These measures aim to prevent a recurrence of the conditions that allowed the alleged crimes to happen.
As the CCRC continues its assessment, the next confirmed legal step depends on whether they refer the case back to the Court of Appeal. If they do, the court will need to determine if new arguments or evidence have emerged that were not considered in the previous refusal of permission. Until then, the conviction remains intact, and the legal battle continues in the corridors of appeal rather than in the public square.



