Atalay, a lawyer elected to represent the earthquake-hit southern province of Hatay in the May 2023 elections, has been held in custody since April 2022. He is serving an 18-year sentence stemming from the Gezi Park trial, a case widely characterized by critics as politically motivated. The central political development driving the current crisis is the Turkish Parliament’s decision to revoke Atalay’s legislative status, a move that directly contradicted prior judgments by the Constitutional Court. By stripping him of his immunity and seat, lawmakers from President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s ruling coalition effectively defied the country’s highest judicial authority, an action observers have described as an unprecedented strike against judicial independence.
The legal and political battle centers on the tension between the executive-backed legislature and the judiciary. The Constitutional Court had previously ruled that the continued detention of Atalay violated his rights and declared the parliament’s move to remove his status “null and void.” Despite these rulings, the Court of Cassation, Turkey’s supreme court of appeal, rejected Atalay’s appeals in September 2023, upholding his conviction for “assisting the overthrow of the government.” This divergence between high courts created a vacuum of legal certainty that the legislature exploited to remove Atalay, arguing that his conviction disqualified him from holding office, regardless of the Constitutional Court’s findings on his detention and rights.
The political significance of this confrontation extends beyond a single lawmaker’s fate. For the ruling coalition, maintaining control over the parliamentary majority and enforcing its interpretation of the law regarding convicted officials has been a priority. However, the opposition views the expulsion as a tool used to silence dissent and undermine the separation of powers. During the vote to strip Atalay of his status, opposition lawmakers banged their tables and booed the decision. Erkan Bas, the leader of Atalay’s leftist Workers’ Party of Turkey, characterized the parliamentary vote as a “coup attempt that is trampling the constitution,” accusing the ruling bloc of revolting against the judiciary and the rule of law.
International human rights organizations have monitored the case closely, aligning with the opposition’s critique of the legal process. Dinushika Dissanayake, Research Director for Europe, the Balkans and Türkiye at Amnesty International, described the Constitutional Court’s earlier ruling in Atalay’s favor as “long overdue” and a “resounding confirmation” that his right to liberty had been violated. Amnesty International identified Atalay as a prisoner of conscience, one of five individuals held behind bars following the Gezi Park trial. The organization has called for the immediate and unconditional release of Atalay and his co-defendants, including Osman Kavala, whom the European Court of Human Rights has twice ordered be released.
The mechanism of the conflict lies in the specific jurisdictional powers of the institutions involved. The Constitutional Court has the authority to review the compatibility of laws and actions with the constitution and to protect fundamental rights. Its rulings are legally binding. However, the Grand National Assembly holds the constitutional power to determine the eligibility of its members. By voting to expel Atalay, the parliament asserted that the legislative branch’s determination of a lawmaker’s status supersedes the Constitutional Court’s findings regarding his detention and rights. This has created a parallel legal reality where Atalay is simultaneously recognized by the highest court as a rights-violated citizen entitled to liberty and by the legislature as a disqualified former member.
Atalay’s hunger strike adds a personal dimension to this institutional deadlock. As a lawyer who represented families in high-profile cases, including the 2014 Soma coal mine explosion and the 2018 Çorlu train derailment, Atalay’s incarceration has been framed by supporters as a result of his professional activism. The strike serves as a non-violent method to draw attention to what his legal team and supporters describe as a gross injustice. While the immediate demand is the restoration of his seat, the broader implication is a test of whether the Turkish judiciary can maintain its independence from political pressure in a polarized environment.
Uncertainty remains regarding the next steps in this legal and political stalemate. The Turkish state has not indicated whether it will comply with the Constitutional Court’s order to reverse the expulsion or release Atalay, given the legislature’s explicit defiance. The case may now return to the courts, potentially leading to further rulings that could exacerbate the institutional crisis. For now, the focus remains on Atalay’s health and the political reaction to his protest, with the opposition using the moment to rally support around the defense of judicial independence.
The situation leaves the Turkish political landscape in a state of acute tension. The ruling coalition faces accusations of eroding democratic norms, while the opposition points to the hunger strike as evidence of a system failing to protect the rights of elected representatives. As the new legislative year unfolds, the resolution of Atalay’s case will be watched as a critical indicator of the health of Turkey’s rule of law and the balance of power between its branches of government.



